Assist CleanTechnica’s work by a Substack subscription or on Stripe.
Final Up to date on: seventeenth August 2025, 10:00 pm
US Power Secretary Chris Wright, who made his fortune by drilling holes within the Earth to entry methane gasoline after which leaving taxpayers to scrub up the mess his firm made, visited the Ames Nationwide Laboratory in Ames, Iowa, to ship a message. He mentioned the US ought to mine and refine its personal vital uncooked supplies as an alternative of letting different counties [ahem, CHINA, ahem] do it. He additionally mentioned it’s time to dispose of all federal subsidies for wind energy, in accordance with the Des Moines Register.
Whereas he was there to cheer on the workers on the Ames Nationwide Laboratory, Wright additionally had some phrases of knowledge he shared with the press. He mentioned federal incentives for wind power “have been round for 33 years, and I believe you’ve seen a mature business develop.” Wind and photo voltaic power must “compete within the market” like each different supply of power, he claimed.
He’s right, in fact. One of many bedrock ideas of the MAGA motion is that authorities shouldn’t be choosing winners and losers within the nice capitalist market, the place Adam Smith’s unseen hand shouldn’t be influenced by favoritism in any approach. At CleanTechnica, we agree utterly. Let’s eradicate any and all subsidies for wind and photo voltaic — and coal, oil, and methane as nicely. Mission 2025 is nothing if not an enormous subsidy for the fossil gas business. Let’s eliminate that whereas we’re at it.
Wright, in fact, shouldn’t be intelligent sufficient to understand that his wealth is a direct byproduct of presidency insurance policies that rewarded the pipeline firms that carry the methane his firm wrested from the bottom, that allowed his drilling rigs to torture the Earth after which stroll away from the injury they did. Legal guidelines that permit drillers to promote their belongings to different firms who then declare chapter when the invoice comes due for such cleanup measures are a subsidy.
Untaxed Externalities Are Subsidies
Financial preparations that impose no price for the hurt performed to the setting by business actions are a subsidy. The medical price of caring for individuals sickened by industrial waste from coal retention ponds are a subsidy. Relieving these liable for pouring trillions of tons of carbon dioxide into the environment of any monetary accountability for his or her actions is a subsidy. Economists usually check with “untaxed externalities” — prices of doing enterprise that get handed off onto the shoulders of others. These are all subsidies of 1 type of one other.
The Worldwide Financial Fund places these “untaxed externalities” related to fossil gas operations at round $5 trillion a 12 months or extra. So our query for Secretary Wright is, how a lot of your private wealth attributable to these subsidies are you keen to offer again to the taxpayers? His reply, in fact, could be “none,” and that tells you all it’s good to find out about his credibility.
Wright then used the chance to bang on his favourite drum. Local weather change is a “actual factor,” he mentioned. “It’s a real bodily phenomenon. But it surely’s simply not even near the world’s best drawback.” Conveniently, he didn’t disclose what these extra severe issues is perhaps. Presumably he’s with the vast majority of MAGAlomaniacs who suppose faculties and universities needs to be compelled to show curricula supplied by Fake Information.
Uncommon Earth And Vital Supplies
Wright’s principal cause for his go to to Ames was to tout the nationwide laboratory’s position in reinvigorating America’s potential to mine and refine uncommon earth minerals and different vital supplies wanted to win the AI race. And, oh, by the way in which, in addition they are important to creating electrical autos and storage batteries.
“We’ve outsourced that abroad,” Wright mentioned. “It’s turn into a nationwide protection drawback for us. It’s turn into a medical drawback for us.” The Ames laboratory “is a pacesetter in bringing these applied sciences and capabilities again to our nation.” Wright famous there are “92 naturally occurring components” within the periodic desk and “the whole lot we do is made up from combos of these components.” He has this specialised data apparently as a result of he’s an engineer, which provides him deep insights into issues which can be opaque to lesser mortals.
The Power Division mentioned Wednesday it will make almost $1 billion in funding accessible to “advance and scale mining, processing and manufacturing applied sciences throughout key levels of the vital minerals and supplies provide chains.” Nobody within the room observed that such funding in itself is a subsidy, or in the event that they did, they have been sensible sufficient to maintain it to themselves. Really, all 17 nationwide analysis laboratories are subsidizing business, so let’s eliminate all of them whereas we’re pursuing our struggle on subsidies. [Editor’s note: Don’t give them any ideas, Steve!]
Bruce Waterman is a Republican congressperson from Arkansas whose main qualification for the job is having a penis. He chairs the Home Committee on Pure Sources and mentioned in Iowa that Alaska alone has entry to 49 vital minerals inside its borders. “We’ve received to begin mining extra. We will’t simply mine it, we’ve received to refine it. We’ve received to make it into these helpful metals that go into all these parts.” Such eloquence, such mastery of the English language, is normal fare within the MAGAverse.
In fact, what the honorable consultant for the good state of Arkansas didn’t say is that the federal government will quick observe the allowing course of for all these new mines. Is there anybody who doesn’t perceive that mining itself is a unclean enterprise with vital environmental impacts? The MAGA crazies are all the time attacking mining for cobalt or copper if the tip merchandise contribute to cleaner autos or renewable power parts, but when it helps different industries, they’re all for it.
The factor that Wright and his ilk are unable to wrap their heads round is that what’s sauce for the goose is sauce for the gander, as my outdated Irish grandmother favored to say. Discussions about subsidies flip into partisan gibberish if it focuses on only one business or one expertise whereas excluding all others. Saying otherwise is only a type of mendacity.
Willful Ignorance
The Intergovernmental Panel on Local weather Change has mentioned the “affect of human exercise on the warming of the local weather system has developed from idea to established reality” and that local weather change “is already affecting many climate and local weather extremes in each area throughout the globe,” resulting in “losses and damages to nature and other people.”
However Chris Wright is aware of issues these bogus scientists don’t. He mentioned concern over local weather change has been used “as a cudgel to make power costlier, to export jobs abroad, to make youngsters have nightmares … and for younger individuals to not wish to have youngsters as a result of they suppose the world’s going to be horrible and harmful going ahead.”
This flaming jackass is head of the US Power Division? Mission 2025 should have devoured his mind. A robust bias in opposition to science is a trademark of fascist societies, which is exactly the trail the US is headed down so long as this MAGA lunacy persists.
Join CleanTechnica’s Weekly Substack for Zach and Scott’s in-depth analyses and excessive degree summaries, join our each day publication, and observe us on Google Information!
Have a tip for CleanTechnica? Need to promote? Need to recommend a visitor for our CleanTech Speak podcast? Contact us right here.
Join our each day publication for 15 new cleantech tales a day. Or join our weekly one on high tales of the week if each day is just too frequent.
CleanTechnica makes use of affiliate hyperlinks. See our coverage right here.
CleanTechnica’s Remark Coverage